Misa or Edvinsson? Debating a potential NHL trade

WHO WOULD YOU RATHER HAVE?? MISA OR EDVINSSON?? One of the most talked about trades in the NHL right now is centered around Simon Edvinsson and Michael Misa, but fans are split on what team would need to add more Pagnotta said himself that they aren't sure if Misa was inquired by the Redwings or offered by the Sharks, but his name was mentioned in Edvinsson talks, and the trade makes a lot of sense from both sides If you were the GM of the Redwings, would you pull a 1-for-1 deal for Misa? Or would you be asking for more? What about as Sharks GM? Personally, I think as GM of either team I would probably make this trade 1 for 1. Both teams have a need at the position they are acquiring, both are young lottery picks, and both sides are associated with some sort of risk and nerve about the deal which probably means it's pretty fair. Additionally, the Wings need to get some help and they have two premiere trade pieces sitting in the press box. I understand trying to get the best deal but they can't nickel and dime themselves too much, and the Sharks are sliding bad to start the year and need a top defenseman that is ready to play right now. It is a match made in heaven, in my opinion COMMENT BELOW WHICH PLAYER YOU WOULD RATHER HAVE?? BETTER FOR SHARKS OR WINGS??? DEBATE ME