How ICAW Worked With Athletes and Creators to Put Carmine on the Public Radar
A major change in food coloring is underway in the United States, but removing one ingredient does not settle what comes next. As food companies reformulate products that use synthetic red dyes, the replacement can carry its own consequences for consumers and animals. That was the opening for The Red Dye Shakeup, a fall 2026 campaign from the International Council for Animal Welfare and MILLIONS.
The campaign focused on carmine, a red color additive made from cochineal insects. It asked a direct question: if companies are already changing their formulas, why replace petroleum-based dyes with an insect-derived color when plant-based options are available?
Eight athletes and lifestyle creators carried that question to their own audiences between September 15 and October 14. Their posts generated more than 1.2 million reported impressions, while a wider group of MILLIONS creators extended the message further. More important than the scale alone was the response. Viewers began checking ingredient lists, sharing what they found and discussing what they wanted brands to use instead.
Why carmine became the question
In April 2025, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services and the Food and Drug Administration announced measures intended to phase petroleum-based synthetic dyes out of the food supply. The FDA has separately revoked authorization for FD&C Red No. 3 in food, with a reformulation deadline of January 15, 2027. The agency has also said that its broader work with industry on six other synthetic dyes is a transition effort, which means the replacement decisions are largely being made product by product.
Carmine is already permitted as a color additive in food, drugs and cosmetics. Because it comes from an animal source and has been associated with allergic reactions in some people, U.S. rules require manufacturers to identify it by name as carmine or cochineal extract rather than hide it behind a generic color label. The FDA's labeling guidance gives consumers a way to find it, but only if they know what the words mean.
ICAW began approaching food companies in January 2026 with two requests: do not use carmine as a replacement for synthetic dyes, and establish a phaseout timeline where carmine is already in use. The organization has pointed to beet extract, anthocyanins from plants such as purple sweet potato and black carrot, paprika oleoresin and lycopene as alternatives that can supply red tones without using insects. ICAW's public explanation of the issue gave the creator campaign a policy goal beyond simply telling audiences that carmine exists.
Eight creators made the issue concrete
Ingredient reformulation can sound remote until someone holds up a familiar package and reads the label. The Red Dye Shakeup was built around that simple act. Each creator made one short-form video, and the posts were staggered over six weeks so the campaign could build recognition without asking every voice to deliver the message in the same way.
The group included fitness creator Jesse Mulley, MMA athlete Jessie Rose Clark, track and field athlete Kate Hall, soccer player Jasmyne Spencer and jiu-jitsu athlete Kaya Anderson. Lifestyle creators Andrew Oporto, Lindsay Pruss and Anne Mok widened the conversation beyond sport. Together, they approached the subject through training, parenting, shopping, dietary choices and everyday label reading.
That range mattered because the campaign did not ask audiences to accept a technical argument on authority. It showed where the ingredient appears and invited people to verify it for themselves. Hall's and Mok's videos were especially natural fits for their existing feeds, according to the campaign report, while several creators used seasonal candy as an entry point during the weeks before Halloween.
What Round One achieved
Across the eight creator posts, ICAW and MILLIONS reported 1,211,344 impressions and 35,621 engagements. Calculated from the post-level figures in the results deck, the campaign produced a weighted engagement rate of 2.94 percent. Against the reported $10,500 investment, that works out to an $8.67 cost per thousand impressions and approximately $0.29 per engagement.
The distribution was not dependent on one account, although the largest pages supplied substantial reach. Mulley's reel recorded 505,000 impressions and 15,554 engagements. Clark's generated 227,000 impressions and 7,046 engagements. Pruss, Oporto and Hall each added more than 80,000 impressions, while the smaller accounts contributed meaningful engagement rates and gave the campaign a wider mix of communities.
The MILLIONS network then added a second layer of distribution. More than 45 athletes and creators reshared the campaign content, producing over 200,000 additional reported impressions and more than 1,200 likes, reactions and shares. Those amplification figures are separate from the eight creator-post totals, so they are best read as evidence of extended circulation rather than folded into a single exact total.
Viewers started checking labels
The campaign report classified 82 percent of the audience response as positive, 12 percent as neutral and 6 percent as negative. At least 80 viewers said they would check their own labels. Others reported finding carmine in products at home, asked about its use in beverages or cosmetics, and discussed plant-based color options.
That is a useful outcome for an awareness campaign because label literacy gives people something specific to do after the video ends. Carmine can be legal and correctly disclosed while still conflicting with a consumer's dietary, ethical or allergy-related priorities. Once viewers know the two names to look for, they can make an informed choice and ask companies a more precise question about reformulation.
The comments also showed the limit of awareness alone. Viewers often reacted to the ingredient itself, but they did not consistently identify the companies making replacement decisions. The results deck notes that the call to action may have contributed to that gap. Future content can keep the accessible label check while giving audiences a clearer route for asking specific brands to commit to plant-based color.
Why athlete and creator voices fit the campaign
Athletes already speak to audiences about ingredients, routines and the choices behind performance. That does not make them food scientists, and the strongest posts did not ask them to play that role. Their value was translation. They could take an unfamiliar term from an ingredient list and connect it to habits their followers already understand: read what is in the product, know what a label means and decide whether it fits your values.
Creators also made the animal-welfare question visible without relying on graphic imagery. A package, a label and a clear explanation were enough. That approach matched ICAW's broader model of evidence-based advocacy, which combines public education with direct engagement of companies and industry decision makers.
Round One should not be treated as proof that a brand changed its formula. It measured reach, engagement and audience response, not corporate reformulation. What it did establish was a substantial audience for the issue and a message that people could act on immediately.
Corporate reformulation is the next test
The shift away from synthetic dyes has created a short decision window. Food companies can treat carmine as a convenient natural color, or they can choose plant-based alternatives and avoid adding more insect-derived coloring to their supply chains. ICAW's campaign is designed to make that choice visible before new formulas become established.
For consumers, the immediate action is modest and verifiable. Check red and pink products for the words carmine or cochineal extract, and ask the company what it plans to use when it replaces synthetic dye. Readers who want more background on the ingredient and ICAW's corporate requests can review ICAW's carmine campaign explanation.
The first round of The Red Dye Shakeup showed that an obscure ingredient can become a public conversation when the message is specific, the messengers are credible to their audiences and the next step is easy to understand. The remaining test is whether companies respond while their reformulation decisions are still being made.
Mentions
1 mentions


