MILLIONS logo
Watch the full interview

Tiffany McCarty Maristela interview on TLH Reckoning

6 min read

Key takeaways

  • Tiffany McCarty joined TLH Reckoning in December 2025 and said her role with the club is still taking shape.
  • McCarty wants to mentor young players and share what she learned about mental health during her soccer career.
  • McCarty said USL W League coaches and volunteers need checks, while players must complete training before participating.
  • McCarty believes poor communication about performance and playing time can harm young players’ mental health and development.
  • McCarty played professional soccer in the United States, Japan, Norway and Iceland.

The Tiffany McCarty Maristela interview centered on McCarty’s move into a role with TLH Reckoning at the end of 2025, her concern that poor coaching communication can affect young players’ mental health, and the checks and training she says are required in the USL W League. McCarty also described how Florida State University shaped her path from youth soccer to professional clubs in the United States, Japan, Norway and Iceland.

How did Tiffany McCarty’s path through Florida State University lead to professional soccer?

Tiffany McCarty began playing soccer at about five or six, progressed through club and school teams, and saw a professional future for herself while at Florida State University. She said being surrounded by college teammates who also wanted to turn pro helped her keep developing, even though her options at the time were different from those available in the United States today.

Choosing soccer as a child

McCarty was doing cheerleading when she asked her mother if she could play soccer. She liked the idea of kicking a ball around and was trying different sports after basketball had not worked out for her. From youth club soccer, she went on to play in high school, college and professionally.

She also came through the United States youth soccer system, starting, she believes, around the under-16 or under-17 level and continuing through the under-23s. That meant substantial travel during high school and college. She identified the under-20 level as an important stage for a player developing toward senior soccer.

Florida State and the professional route

McCarty’s freshman year at Florida State was 2008. She recalled thinking that she could play professionally beyond college, but said that, at the time, going pro before completing school would have meant looking overseas rather than entering a United States league. Her teammates’ ambitions made college an environment where she could work toward that goal while earning her degree.

She later played professionally in the United States, Japan, Norway and Iceland. McCarty said those different experiences helped her grow both on and off the field.

Why did Tiffany McCarty join TLH Reckoning in Tallahassee?

Tiffany McCarty was drawn to TLH Reckoning because it is based in Tallahassee, the city where she spent her college years at Florida State University. She joined at the end of 2025 and said the connection offered a way to give back to a community that had been important to her development.

A return to Tallahassee

As McCarty considered working behind the scenes in soccer, she looked into the Tallahassee team. People associated her with Florida State, and she felt a connection between that part of her career and the club’s work. A former Florida State player whom she knew was also a connection to the team.

A role still taking shape

McCarty said she came aboard in December 2025 and was still learning how she could contribute. She is invested in the club and wants to work more behind the scenes, particularly through mentoring players. She also expressed interest in the administrative side without presenting that as a settled responsibility.

Her main involvement is with the club’s USL W League team. She said TLH Reckoning also has a youth academy that provides a path toward the W League side, the club’s highest level. Having played in the W League when she was younger and again as a veteran player, she brings experience from both stages to her new role.

What did Tiffany McCarty say about mental health in youth soccer?

Tiffany McCarty wants to share the mental lessons of her playing career with young soccer players, including those in TLH Reckoning’s academy. She said athletes must adapt as teams and individual roles change, and that understanding those changes matters off the field as well as during matches.

Earlier in her career, McCarty did not think of the mental side of soccer as a major issue. Playing for different teams changed her view. A player’s role, she explained, will not always stay the same, so learning to handle that uncertainty is part of development.

That experience is one reason she wants mentorship to be part of her work with younger players. Although she is mostly involved with the USL W League team, she said she would like to pass on what she has learned to academy players as well. In her view, conversations about mental health in the sport have improved but still need more attention.

What did Tiffany McCarty say about USL W League safety checks?

Tiffany McCarty said coaches and volunteers must complete background and reference checks before they can have contact with minor athletes, while players must complete required training before playing. She described a system that continues to flag changes in a person’s background-check status rather than treating the initial check as the end of the process.

Checks and training before participation

McCarty said the league uses a portal for its requirements. She also praised training that helps coaches and players recognize appropriate behavior and warning signs. For players under 18, she said parental consent is required for the courses, bringing parents into that part of the process.

Keeping requirements visible

Asked what would be useful to manage in one place, McCarty described a profile for each person showing which criteria had been met, what was missing and whether anything had been flagged. She said keeping those requirements current helps protect coaches as well as players.

She also sees value in young players learning those standards before they move on to college. Knowing what is expected—and what is not appropriate—can stay with them beyond their time in a youth or W League environment, she said.

Why does Tiffany McCarty want better communication from youth soccer coaches?

Tiffany McCarty said safety requirements cannot address every problem a young athlete may face. Coaches can also affect development through the way they communicate about performance, playing time and a player’s place on the team. She wants mental-health training to help coaches treat those conversations with the same care they give physical development.

McCarty said a young player should feel valued regardless of their role. When a coach does not communicate clearly, she believes the effect can reach beyond immediate playing time and become a mental-health concern. She identified healthy communication among coaches and teammates as a weakness in sports generally, not only women’s soccer.

She suggested training on mental health and communication as one way to improve that environment. McCarty also confirmed that these concerns helped inspire her to write a book; she did not give its title or further details.

What advice did Tiffany McCarty give people who want to mentor young athletes?

Tiffany McCarty advised prospective mentors to think about what they had, what they lacked and what they wished had been available when they were young. They can then bring those lessons into whichever role they choose in sports. For her, mentoring is also a chance to learn from the next generation.

Reflecting on why she wants to work with younger players, McCarty put her motivation this way:

things that I wish I had, I want to give that back to the younger generation.

She said that exchange is not one-sided. Younger athletes teach her about the difficulties they face, just as she can share lessons from her own career. Her advice was to pair that kind of self-reflection with action rather than stopping at the intention to help.

Who is Tiffany McCarty?

Tiffany McCarty is an athlete and content creator transitioning into the women’s heptathlon in track and field. Her soccer experience includes the National Women’s Soccer League, European leagues and the Women’s Champions League.

Watch the full interview

Questions from the interview

When did Tiffany McCarty join TLH Reckoning?

Tiffany McCarty said she joined TLH Reckoning in December 2025 and was still developing her role with the club.

What does Tiffany McCarty do with TLH Reckoning?

Tiffany McCarty said she is mostly involved with TLH Reckoning’s USL W League team. She wants to mentor younger players and become more involved behind the scenes.

Do USL W League coaches and volunteers need background checks?

Tiffany McCarty said coaches and volunteers must complete background and reference checks before having contact with minor athletes. She described the background-check process as continuous.

Do young USL W League players need parental consent for training?

Tiffany McCarty said players under 18 need parental consent to take the required training courses.

Which countries did Tiffany McCarty play professional soccer in?

Tiffany McCarty said she played professionally in the United States, Japan, Norway and Iceland.

Did Tiffany McCarty write a book about athletes’ mental health?

Tiffany McCarty confirmed that her concerns about athletes’ mental health helped inspire her to write a book. She did not give its title.

In this interview

More from Maristela

  • Nátalie Andrade Maristela interview on her move to Germany

    News

    Nátalie Andrade Maristela interview on her move...

    Maristela

    29 Oct 2026 at 06:07 PM

  • Lucas Lima Maristela interview on life after college soccer

    News

    Lucas Lima Maristela interview on life after...

    Maristela

    27 Oct 2026 at 04:19 AM

  • Luisa Camara Maristela interview on becoming a goalkeeper

    News

    Luisa Camara Maristela interview on becoming a...

    Maristela

    23 Oct 2026 at 05:47 AM