MILLIONS logo
Watch the full interview

Phil Batway Knockouts and 3 Counts interview on Halloween Havoc

6 min read

Key takeaways

  • Phil Batway called NXT his current favorite wrestling show and preferred AEW’s pay-per-views to its weekly television.
  • Batway thought Grayson Waller’s return to NXT had renewed his momentum and favored him to retain against Tony D’Angelo.
  • Batway said Zilla Fatu had main-roster potential but still had things to learn.
  • Batway wanted Kelani Jordan to move to WWE’s women’s main-roster midcard division.
  • Batway predicted a close Detroit Lions win over the Minnesota Vikings if Detroit’s defense played well.

The Phil Batway Knockouts and 3 Counts interview took place during an NXT Halloween Havoc watch-along, where the wrestling fan backed Grayson Waller’s title run, discussed Zilla Fatu’s potential and explained why he prefers AEW pay-per-views to its weekly shows. The conversation also moved through Shotzi Blackheart’s TNA prospects, the Detroit Lions and Batway’s own Halloween memories.

What did Phil Batway remember about Halloween and say about Shotzi Blackheart?

Phil Batway’s funniest Halloween memory was dressing as a cheerleader with Cory and Mike, though he said wearing a skirt gave him a new appreciation for the people who wear them regularly. As Halloween Havoc began, he also backed the prospect of a Shotzi Blackheart and Rosemary storyline in TNA.

The cheerleader costumes

Batway did not describe the costume outing as his worst trick-or-treating experience. He called it the funniest one he could recall. Cory, he added, had long hair and could have passed in the outfit.

Shotzi Blackheart and Rosemary

After Knockouts and 3 Counts brought up its recent conversation with Shotzi, Batway reacted to the possibility of a story involving her and Rosemary. He thought the feud could work and said TNA knew how to handle that kind of storyline. His response was an expectation, not a claim that a match had been announced.

Later, when horror films came up, Batway said he does not watch many movies. His stepson had tried to get him to watch The Conjuring, but Batway said he had too much to do around the house to spend much time on films.

What did Phil Batway say about NXT Halloween Havoc’s wrestlers?

Phil Batway called NXT his favorite wrestling show at the moment and identified several wrestlers he thought could progress. He saw promise in Izzi Dame, liked Hank and Tank, and thought Charlie Dempsey’s Birthright story gave him more to work with than his previous direction.

Izzi Dame and Hank and Tank

Watching Dame face Zaria, Batway said Dame had a bright future, citing her look and ability to talk. He was less certain about how her story with The Culling would end. His comments were about her potential rather than a prediction that she would immediately move to WWE’s main roster.

Batway also liked Hank and Tank. Their presentation reminded him somewhat of The Public Enemy, whom he particularly liked in ECW. He agreed there was a Heavy Machinery resemblance, too, while making clear that he was not as enthusiastic about every comparison raised during the watch-along.

Charlie Dempsey and Birthright

When the discussion turned to Dempsey, Batway said the Birthright storyline was better for him than what he had before. He believed Dempsey could benefit from the right manager and expressed interest in seeing more of Dempsey’s father in that role. Batway also thought members of the group could eventually work on their own, though he was less certain about Dempsey’s path than some of the others.

What did Phil Batway say about Zilla Fatu at NXT Halloween Havoc?

Phil Batway thought Zilla Fatu had the makings of a main-roster star but still had things to learn. He pointed to Fatu’s independent-wrestling experience as an advantage and followed his Halloween Havoc match with Charlie Dempsey closely, including its graveyard setting and physical finish.

Batway’s view was that Fatu already had a measure of star power. The remaining question, as he saw it, was how much more Fatu would develop before a move to the main roster. He contrasted Fatu’s background with Solo Sikoa’s time in NXT, saying the independent experience made a difference.

During the match, Batway reacted to the use of shovels, a chain and the surrounding graveyard props. He also noted the scorpion reference in Fatu’s presentation. Those details held his attention beyond the question of who would win.

The Dempsey discussion continued after the match. Batway liked the story built around Birthright, but still wanted a clearer direction for Dempsey as an individual. He regarded the group as a useful step rather than necessarily its members’ final form.

What did Phil Batway predict for the Detroit Lions and discuss about the Tennessee Titans?

Phil Batway expected a close Detroit Lions win over the Minnesota Vikings, arguing that Minnesota’s offense could be the difference if Detroit’s defense played well. A Tennessee Titans fan, he also discussed his own team’s difficulty finishing drives and the effect he hoped Cade Mays would have on its offensive line.

Batway’s Lions prediction was conditional: Detroit needed its defense to exploit the matchup. As the conversation turned to the Titans, he acknowledged that it was a frustrating time to follow the team, even after a win. He separated the ability to move the ball from the ability to reach the end zone.

Penalties along the offensive line were another concern he raised. Batway thought getting Mays back at center would eventually help stabilize that unit. These were his assessments of the teams during the watch-along, not reports of how either team’s next game turned out.

What did Phil Batway say about AEW pay-per-views and NXT’s women’s division?

Phil Batway praised AEW’s pay-per-views while saying its weekly television was harder for him to watch. At Halloween Havoc, he also wanted to see Kelani Jordan move to WWE’s main roster and considered how a title change involving Wren Sinclair might affect Wren’s relationship with Kendal Grey.

Batway drew a sharp distinction between AEW’s major events and its regular shows:

Their weekly shows a tough watch for me.

That criticism did not change his broader interest in wrestling across promotions. He said he was a fan of professional wrestling generally and had earlier identified NXT as his current favorite show, while giving AEW the edge for pay-per-views.

Kelani Jordan’s next step

Batway thought Jordan had matured enough for a main-roster move. He specifically wanted to see her in the women’s midcard division and believed she could fill a need there as a heel. He was open to Wren winning their title match partly because it could free Jordan for that move; Jordan instead retained during the watch-along.

Wren Sinclair and Kendal Grey

Before the result, Batway considered whether either Wren or Kendal might turn against the other. He thought Kendal could make the stronger long-term heel, particularly if jealousy over Wren winning a championship became part of their story. He framed both possibilities as speculation about where NXT could take them.

What did Phil Batway think of Shiloh Hill and Naraku?

Phil Batway believed Shiloh Hill could eventually become a world champion despite the silliness some viewers saw in his character. He was also interested in Naraku’s move from New Japan to NXT, expecting that NXT might give the veteran time to adjust to its style before considering a main-roster move.

Asked about Hill’s ceiling, Batway pointed to Mick Foley as an example of an unconventional character who became a world champion. He was impressed by Hill’s improvement and enjoyed the cinematic, haunted-house elements that threaded through the Halloween Havoc match with Naraku.

Batway knew Naraku from his New Japan run as EVIL. He speculated that Naraku might appear in the Royal Rumble and move up after WrestleMania, while acknowledging that NXT could first use time to settle him into a different presentation. A match with Finn Bálor was another possibility he said he would find interesting.

What did Phil Batway say about Grayson Waller at Halloween Havoc?

Phil Batway liked Grayson Waller’s renewed NXT presentation and thought Waller had been poorly served by parts of his main-roster run. He favored Waller retaining against Tony D’Angelo, in part because it would leave open confrontations with major names such as John Cena or CM Punk.

Batway had long been a Waller fan. He rated Waller’s ability to talk highly and felt some previous pairings simply had not worked for him. The return to NXT, in Batway’s view, had given Waller fresh momentum rather than exposed a lack of ability.

He also wanted Waller’s in-ring work to get its due. Batway raised the idea of a future promo exchange with CM Punk, though the conversation also recognized the booking problem of putting Waller opposite someone of Punk’s standing. Other possible opponents discussed included Seth Rollins.

Batway thought Tony D’Angelo might be close to a main-roster move himself. That made a Waller retention plausible to him, but he discussed both men’s futures as predictions, not confirmed plans. Waller retained during the watch-along, keeping the attention on what NXT might do with him next.

Watch the full interview

Questions from the interview

What did Phil Batway dress as for Halloween?

Phil Batway recalled dressing as a cheerleader with Cory and Mike. He called it a funny Halloween memory and said wearing a skirt was uncomfortable.

Did Phil Batway think Zilla Fatu was ready for WWE’s main roster?

Phil Batway thought Zilla Fatu could become a main-roster star, but said he still had things to learn. He viewed Fatu’s independent-wrestling experience as an advantage.

Which wrestling show was Phil Batway’s favorite?

Phil Batway called NXT his current favorite wrestling show. He preferred AEW for pay-per-views but found its weekly shows harder to watch.

Did Phil Batway want Kelani Jordan to move to the main roster?

Yes. Phil Batway said Kelani Jordan had matured and could help WWE’s women’s midcard division, particularly as a heel.

Did Phil Batway pick Grayson Waller to retain against Tony D’Angelo?

Phil Batway thought Grayson Waller had a good chance of retaining against Tony D’Angelo. Waller retained during their NXT Halloween Havoc watch-along.

In this interview

More from Knockouts and 3 Counts